Monday, September 28, 2015

Theoretical vs Application of Cord Cutting: My Summer Without Direct TV

  Even the most sound of theories must pass the test of application and sometimes you must learn to live with the results. 



  It was April of this year when I decided to reevaluate how we allocate our money toward our static bills.  I had been for years paying Verizon $24 per month for telephone service just to support our internet use that was an additional $27 per month for a service that could not nearly keep up with the quickly increasing number of web enabled devices in our home.  I made the decision to drop both services and change over to Comcast Xfinity.  The total amount paid is nearly the same and I increased my wifi capacity more than five fold……a win!

  This success made me even more brazen as I looked at my Direct TV bill of $114 per month and asked myself if I truly value television to the tune of $1,368 per year.  That’s a no frills deal with zero subscriptions, though I was paying $36 per month for my Genie HD DVR system to three TVs.  I could afford the payment but I resented paying it in a way I could afford $9 for a McDonald’s burger but I won’t pay it.  That’s when I started reading up on the cord cutters and how much there is to be saved with streaming services…..and I wanted in.  The plan I came to was as follows:

WWE NETWORK & AMAZON PRIME (already paying)
WWE - $10 monthly = $120 annual
Amazon Prime = $100 annual

STREAMING OPTIONS  
SlingTV with bonus sports - $25 monthly = $300 annual
HuluPlus - $8 monthly = $96 annual
Netflix - $9 monthly = $108 annual
One time purchase – 1 Fire TV stick, 3 Fire TVs = $340        

DIRECT TV – 113.49 monthly = 1,361.88 annual
STREAMING – 42.00 monthly = 504.00 annual
TOTAL SAVINGS - $71.49 monthly = $857.88 annual

  Easy enough, right?  Saving $857.88 a year and I still get to see about 85% of what our family is accustomed to watching…..just not the same day or always in HD and I can’t record anything but for that kind of savings I was game.  Take away the creature comforts and you’ll realize you don’t need them.  Season finales had come and gone when I made the changeover so we had a Summer to test drive the idea.  I purchased three Amazon Fire TV boxes ($100/ea) for the living room, bedroom and my oldest son’s room and one Fire TV Stick ($40) for a playroom shared by all three of my boys age 9,4 & 4.  I am very pleased with the Amazon Fire TV products and continue to use them to run all of our streaming apps.  Point of caution….spend the extra money on the box vs. the stick as the performance quality is night and day.  All in all it sounds like my cost cutting plan was working out great.  My only early gripe (that I knew going in to things) was giving up the YES Network and all of my Yankee games.  I spent $20 for a season long MLB Radio subscription.  We then also added a $10/mo local channels subscription to our Comcast service so we could watch network shows when they aired in the fall and to watch our local news.  In total I had now spent $360 on additional equipment and subscription and an extra $10/mo to enjoy a portion of my previous TV entertainment…..roughly half of my initial anticipated annual savings.  Still, in the long run I was excited at the future savings as I settled into the streaming life. 

  Early on things were going along better than anticipated.  Between my Amazon Prime, Netflix and Hulu subscriptions my twin 4 year olds programming needs were exceeded and they are the toughest customers in the house.  It was also early on that the one (literal) glitch began to present itself…Sling.  Sling TV was the service that clinched my decision to move to streaming and ultimately it is the reason I am returning to a traditional TV service.  This service is a terrific concept that just isn’t ready for my business yet.  When it works, it’s great.  Picture quality is in perfect HD and the channels I got for $25 suited my needs just fine….when it worked.  This is a very glitchy service and the issue was not on my end as we run HBO.GO, Amazon Prime, WWE Network, Crackle, Netflix and Hulu with almost zero interruption.  When you’re marketing a live TV service, freezing picture, buffering and having to stare at a blank screen with a yellow spinning disc is a big issue.  We continued along with the service but as summer drew to a close and the fall programming began to return we immediately began to realize the value we had before vs. the economy plan we went for.

  My wife and I defer to the boys for programming up to their bed times and when we have that bit of quiet and can unwind with a show it’s actually a big deal for us.  We sat down to watch the season premiere of The Goldbergs last week and in the first scene of the show one of the twins started yelling down to us for potty help.  Happens all the time….only now there is no pause button….we aren’t recording the show to start watching after they settle in.  One of us (me) had to leave the room and miss the show right up to the first commercial break.  



  What my wife said next was the death blow to the cord cutting project…..”ya know, Blacklist and Walking Dead are back soon…..this is going to happen again”. 



  Is TV THAT big of a deal? No.  I’ll say this though….when you’ve been married a dozen years, you’ve been parenting for a decade, you never go anywhere or have any friends to hang out with, that hour or so to sit down with another adult, watch a show you both enjoy to help you unwind from your day is a pretty valuable experience and worth a few more bucks to enhance it.  When it’s all said and done regaining the ability to pause and record TV with a terabyte of storage to watch when you’re able, to get all my Yankees games back and as a perk get Sunday Ticket Max for the season and the premium channels for 3 months is well worth every penny of the special intro rate of a $62/mo bill for the first year.  Next October when that bill becomes $109 I will have to read this to remind myself that while I don’t like paying so much to watch TV, that’s not what I’m paying for.


  Cord cutting and cafeteria TV subscriptions are the future…..I’m just not there yet.